mt logoMyToken
ETH Gas
عربى

Chainflip Offers Its Attacker 10%. The Split Hides a $1,678 Ether Price

يجمعcollect
شاركshare
blockchain8 MAIN

Chainflip Labs has published the terms on which it will stop pursuing the person who emptied its vaults, and the document at chainflip.io/return is arithmetic before it is a negotiation. It names four assets taken on 21 November, 122.86137042 BTC, 520.2243399 ETH, 3,249,631.41 USDC and 758,141.33 USDT, and asks for two back: 110.57523337 BTC and 2,618.1 ETH, both by 18:38 UTC on 23 November 2026.

The bitcoin side is a textbook 90/10 split. 110.57523337 is 90.0000% of 122.86137042, which leaves the attacker 12.28613705 BTC, or $744,687 at the $60,612 that CoinGecko recorded at 18:25 UTC on 22 November. “Keep 10% as a bounty and return 90%,” the notice reads.

The ether side is not a textbook anything. Chainflip wants 2,618.1 ETH, which is 503% of the 520.2243399 ETH it says was stolen. The extra 2,097.8756601 ETH can only come from the $4,007,772.74 in stablecoins, and exactly one exchange rate makes that addition close: $1,677.75 per ether.

The Number That Closes the Ether Leg

At $1,677.75, the stablecoins convert to 2,388.78 ETH. Add the 520.2243399 ETH taken directly and the attacker’s total ETH-equivalent comes to 2,909.00, of which 90% is 2,618.1. The demand is a percentage of a portfolio, not a list of coins, and the portfolio is priced at a rate the notice never states. Anyone reading the two addresses and two amounts without doing that division would miss it.

That matters because ether has moved since the notice was written. At the $1,710.95 CoinGecko quoted at 18:25 UTC on 22 November, the same stablecoins buy 2,342.43 ETH rather than 2,388.78. Adding the stolen 520.2243399 ETH gives 2,862.65, which is 244.55 ETH more than the notice asks for. Returning the exact quantities it lists would hand over $11,181,624 at today’s prices, 90.6% of the loss rather than 90.0%. The percentage is fixed in coins, not in dollars, and a two percent move in ether is enough to shift it.

The retained bounty works out at 12.28613705 BTC plus 290.9 ETH. At the same 18:25 snapshot that is $1,242,487, or 4.9% of FLIP’s $25.3 million market capitalisation.

What the Twelve Million Is Made Of

Repricing each stolen asset at the 18:25 UTC CoinGecko snapshot gives a total of $12,344,724:

Asset Amount taken Value at 18:25 UTC Share
Bitcoin 122.86137042 BTC $7,446,873 60.3%
USDC and USDT 3,249,631.41 + 758,141.33 $4,007,772.74 32.5%
Ether 520.2243399 ETH $890,078 7.2%
Total $12,344,724

Six tenths of the value is bitcoin, and that is the part the protocol did not disclose when the drain was first reported. Our coverage of the first batch priced the Ethereum vault outflow at $4.88 million from three transfers visible on Blockscout. The notice’s $12.34 million is 2.53 times that number, and the gap is not a restatement of the same coins. It is 122.86 BTC that was not in the earlier figure at all, worth more than the entire Ethereum batch on its own.

Against the token, the loss is close to half of it. FLIP traded at $0.2937 at 18:25 UTC on 22 November, with a market capitalisation of $25,286,565 across 86.08 million circulating tokens, down 15.6% in 24 hours. The stolen assets are worth 48.8% of that. The bounty is worth 4.9%. A protocol that pays the second number closes an incident that is twenty times larger than what it pays to close it.

FLIP token price chart over seven days to 22 November 2026, falling from about $0.48 to $0.29
FLIP traded between $0.4835 and $0.2803 over the seven days to 22 November 2026. Source: CoinGecko hourly data, chart by BlockchainReporter.

The 15.6% decline is a price the market set, and this article cannot show what share of it the notice caused. What is measurable is the ratio. At $25.3 million the token capitalises at just over twice the stolen amount.

The Addresses Predate the Theft

Both return addresses come from Chainflip’s standing security policy rather than from this incident. The policy repository’s README, last updated 17 November 2026, names “our safe-return address for the Governance Council at Chainflip Labs is 0x38a4BCC04f5136e6408589A440F495D7AD0F34DB” and “the Bitcoin safe return address of bc1qux4nruxvwfxyv2n5d4fw0a363d4lxn5f45rats” ( Chainflip security policy ).

The same document supplies the legal frame the notice is operating inside. “Any party that sends safeguarded assets back to the Governance Council will be protected under no-legal-action rights and shall be rewarded with a percentage of the secured assets,” it says. The sentence leaves the percentage blank. The notice fills it at 10% and attaches a deadline to it, which is the only new policy content in the exchange.

On-chain, both addresses were empty when checked at 18:45 UTC on 22 November. The Bitcoin address has never received a transaction, according to mempool.space . The Ethereum address holds 10 wei, the smallest unit of ether, and has sent one transaction in its history, according to a public node read confirmed on a second endpoint through Etherscan . No partial return had arrived by that check, and the notice does not describe a mechanism for paying in instalments.

What Chainflip Says It Traced

The notice is unusually specific about the preparation it attributes to the attacker. It cites “the Tornado Cash funding on 11 November, the FLIP purchase, the validator account registered on 20 November and the server behind it.” It then states: “We have identified the mechanism of key exposure and have prevented such future attacks.”

It also claims leverage rather than proof. “You have made some mistakes in how you conducted this attack and we believe law enforcement will be able to establish an identity based on the metadata you left behind and the particular services you used.” And: “every withdrawal from the Tornado Cash pools you used is being watched.” Those are statements about capability. The notice does not say an identity is known, it does not name the number of validators involved, and it publishes no incident report. Chainflip’s front end still carries the line “Chainflip services are temporarily unavailable” ( chainflip.io ), and the notice carries no reopening date.

The recovery economics explain the tone. Ten percent of $12.34 million is $1.23 million, which is 4.9% of the value the market still assigns to the protocol’s token. Set against the cost of a prosecution that may never produce a seizure, that is a cheap option to buy, and it converts a public failure into a recovery if it works.

Sixteen Times the September Loss

Chainflip’s own history supplies the comparison. In September the protocol lost 736,442.17 USDT from its Tron integration and paused operations until the following Monday ( our report ). Validators approved a compensation plan that the protocol valued at $748,935.16 once fees and surplus balances were counted. The November loss is 16.8 times that one, and it includes bitcoin, which the September incident never touched.

The September recovery was tractable because the loss sat inside one chain’s integration and could be covered from remaining Tron funds and surplus USDC. A $12.34 million hole spread across three assets and at least two chains is a different problem, and the bounty asks for repayment in bitcoin and ether rather than in the stablecoins that made up a third of the loss. Whoever holds the funds must buy 2,388.78 ETH of exposure at the notice’s rate, or already hold it.

What the Notice Leaves Open

Four questions go unanswered. Who absorbs the shortfall, whether liquidity providers, the treasury or token holders, is not stated anywhere in the document. Whether vaults other than the ones named were touched is not addressed. What happens at 18:39 UTC on 23 November if nothing arrives has no specific answer beyond “We will pursue this as hard as we can, for as long as it takes.” And whether a partial payment would earn a partial safe harbour is not said.

For a notice written to be read by one person, that silence is deliberate. For the people who supplied the vaults, it means the only number they have is the deadline.

The Clock

The deadline is 18:38 UTC on 23 November 2026, twenty-four hours and thirteen minutes after the price snapshot used in this article. Two addresses, two amounts, one percentage. If a transfer lands, the notice commits to treating the incident as a white hat recovery, asking no further questions and withdrawing the reports and complaints filed with law enforcement agencies.

If nothing lands, Chainflip has said what it will do in general terms and nothing in specific ones. The vaults stay shut, the token is worth $25.3 million, and the person holding 122.86 BTC has a day to decide whether 12.29 of them is the better outcome.

Data: Chainflip Labs notice , CoinGecko price snapshot at 18:25 UTC on 22 November 2026, mempool.space and a public Ethereum node read at 18:45 UTC.

This article is not intended as financial advice. Educational purposes only.

The post Chainflip Offers Its Attacker 10%. The Split Hides a $1,678 Ether Price appeared first on BlockchainReporter .

إخلاء المسؤولية: تعود حقوق نشر هذه المقالة إلى المؤلف الأصلي ولا تمثل MyToken(www.mytokencap.com)الآراء والمواقف ؛ يرجى الاتصال بنا إذا كانت لديك أسئلة حول المحتوى وحقوق التأليف والنشر وما إلى ذلك.
community_x_prefix
X(https://x.com/MyTokencap)
community_tg_prefixcommunity_tg_name
(https://t.me/mytokenGroup)
القراءة ذات الصلة